Digital Music Doctor Digital Music Doctor
Pro Audio
Video Tutorials
For Musicians

 

DAW Software Shootout-Audio
Explain the Ratings

Go to Ratings

Explain the Rating

What is this?

Explain the rating

Summary

Sonar X1

Cubase 6

Pro Tools 10

Live 8

Digital Performer 7

FL Studio 10

Logic Pro 9

Category

Audio Environment

Sample Rates

192 kHz max listed

192 kHz max

96 kHz max

96 kHz max

192 kHz max

192 kHz max

192 kHz max

Project Bit Depth

16, 24, 32 & 64-bit floating point; multiple bit depths per project

16, 24, & 32-bit floating point; multiple bit depths per project

16, 24, & 32-bit floating point; multiple bit depths per project

16, 24, & 32-bit floating point; multiple bit depths per project

16, 24 & 32-bit floating point; multiple bit depths per project

16, 24, & 32-bit floating point; multiple bit depths per project

16 & 24; single bit depth per session

Dithering Algorithm

POW-r, rectangular

Apogee UV22HR

POW-r, TPDF (triangular)

POW-r, triangular

Not stated

Not stated

POW-r

Stereo Pan Laws

6 stereo pan laws

4 stereo pan laws

4 stereo pan laws

single stereo pan law

single stereo pan law

2 stereo pan laws

3-stereo pan laws

Track Channel Format

Track format can be mono, stereo, or surround

Track format can be mono, stereo, or surround

Track format must be either mono or stereo

Track format can be mono or stereo

Track format must be either mono or stereo

Track format can be mono or stereo

Track format can be mono, stereo, or surround

Freeze Tracks

Yes

Yes

Bounce & auto import

Yes

Yes

Track mixer record

Yes

Batch Processing

All realtime plug-ins plus additional functions

All realtime plug-ins plus additional functions

All realtime plug-ins plus additional functions

No

All realtime plug-ins plus additional functions

3 FX available for batch processing

All realtime plug-ins plus additional functions (Soundtrack Pro)

Plug-in Types Supported

DX & VST

VST

RTAS & AAX

VST & AU

MAS & VST

DX & VST

AU

Plug-in Delay Compensation

Yes

Yes

Yes

Yes

Yes

Yes

Yes

External FX Integration

Yes

Yes

Yes

Yes

No

Yes

Yes

Audio Interfaces

Most interfaces supported

Most interfaces supported

Most interfaces supported

Most interfaces supported

Most interfaces supported

Most interfaces supported

Most interfaces supported

Audio Driver Support

ASIO, WDM, MME

ASIO, MME

ASIO, Core Audio

ASIO, Core Audio

Core Audio

ASIO, WDM

Core Audio

Meters

Meter Routing

Pre/post fader displays

Pre/post fader displays

Pre/post fader displays

Post fader displays

Post fader displays

Post fader displays; pre-fader displays with WaveCandy plug-in

Post fader displays

Meter Display

Peak & RMS, Peak Markers

Peak

Peak

Peak

Peak

Peak

Peak

Meter Scaling

Adjustable scaling

No scaling control

No scaling control

No scaling control

MeterBridge

Scaling on WaveCandy plug-in.

Exponential & linear scaling

Overall Rating

 

 

 

Go to Ratings

Explain the Rating

What is this?

Explain the rating

Summary

Sonar X1

Cubase 6

Pro Tools 10

Live 8

Digital Performer 7

FL Studio 10

Logic Pro 9

Category

Mixing & Mastering

Fades

Real time fade in/out for individual clips; automatic cross-fades; fade curve control

Real time fade in/out for individual events; automatic cross-fades; fade curve control

Real time fade in/out for individual events; automatic cross-fades; fade curve control

Real time fade in/out for individual events; automatic cross-fades; fade curve control

Real time fade in/out for individual events; automatic cross-fades; fade curve control

Batch fades only for clips; no crossfades

Real time fade in/out for individual regions; automatic cross-fades

FX
Plug-ins

Delay & Echo

Basic

Basic & Multitple

Basic & Multitple

Basic & Multitple

Basic & Multitple

Basic & Multitple

Basic & Multitple

Distortion

Variety of Distortion FX

Variety of Distortion FX

Variety of Distortion FX

Variety of Distortion FX

Variety of Distortion FX

Variety of Distortion FX

Variety of Distortion FX

Dynamics

Basic & Multiband

Basic & Multiband

Basic

Basic & Multiband

Basic & Multiband

Basic & Multiband

Basic & Multiband

Modulation

Basic

Basic & Special FX

Basic & Special FX

Basic

Basic & Special FX

Basic

Basic & Special FX

Reverb

Track, Mastering & Convolution

Track, Mastering & Convolution

Track & Mastering

Track & Mastering

Track, Mastering & Convolution

Track

Track, Mastering & Convolution

Harmonics

Warming & Guitar Amp Sim

Warming & Guitar Amp Sim

Guitar Amp Sim

Warming & Resonator

Warming & Guitar Amp Sim

Guitar Amp Sim

Warming & Guitar Amp Sim

Spatial

Spatial Imaging

Special Panning & Stereo Imaging

Stereo Imaging

Special Panning & Stereo Imaging

Special Panning & Stereo Imaging

Special Panning & Stereo Imaging

Special Panning & Stereo Imaging

Spectrum Analyzer

Yes

Yes

No

Yes

No

Yes

Included in EQ

Panning

Separate & combined panning (plug-in)

Separate & combined channel panning

Separate channel panning

Combined channel panning

Separate & combined panning (plug-in)

Combined channel panning

Combined channel panning

Routing

Multi-Level routing to buses&main outputs

Multi-Level routing to buses&main outputs

Multi-Level routing to buses&main outputs

Multi-Level routing to buses&main outputs

Multi-Level routing to buses&main outputs

Multi-Level routing to buses&main outputs

Multi-Level routing to buses&main outputs

Inserts

No limit stated on inserts, all pre-fader

8 FX insert slots, 6 pre-fader & 2 post-fader

5 inserts, all pre-fader

No limit stated on inserts, all pre-fader

No limit stated on inserts, pre & post fader

8 inserts, all pre-fader

No limit stated on inserts, all pre-fader

Sends

No limit stated on sends, both pre-fader & post-fader

8 sends, both pre-fader & post-fader

10 sends, both pre-fader & post-fader

No limit stated on sends, both pre-fader & post-fader

No limit stated on sends, both pre-fader & post-fader

64 sends, post fader

No limit stated on sends, both pre-fader & post-fader

Sidechain

Yes (selected plug-ins only)

Yes (selected plug-ins only)

Yes (selected plug-ins only)

Yes (selected plug-ins only)

Yes (selected plug-ins only)

Yes (selected plug-ins only)

Yes (selected plug-ins only)

EQ

6-band EQ including high & low pass/shelving curves

4-band EQ including high & low pass/shelving curves

5-band EQ including high & low pass/shelving curves

6-band EQ including high & low pass/shelving curves

8-band EQ including high & low pass/shelving curves

7-band EQ including high & low pass/shelving curves

4-band EQ including high & low pass/shelving curves

Overall Rating

 

 

 

Go to Ratings

Explain the Rating

What is this?

Explain the rating

Summary

Sonar X1

Cubase 6

Pro Tools 10

Live 8

Digital Performer 7

FL Studio 10

Logic Pro 9

Category

Audio File Management

File Types

Import

19 file types including Wave, AIFF, MPEG, Windows Media

15 file types including Wave, AIFF, MPEG, Windows Media, Ogg, Wave 64, REX

MPEG, Sound Designer, Wave, Windows Media, AIFF, REX, MP3

WAV, AIFF, Ogg

12 file types including WAV, AIFF, MP3, CAF, SD

WAV, MP3, Ogg, REX

AIFF, Wave, CAF, Sound Designer II

Export

RIFF Wave, Broadcast Wave, Real Audio, Windows Media

Wave, Wave 64, AIFF, Ogg, RealMedia, Windows Media,

Wave, Windows Media, AIFF

WAV, AIFF

WAV, AIFF, CAF, SD II

WAV, Ogg

AIFF, Wave, CAF, SD II

CD Ripping/Burning

Ripping & burning

Ripping

Ripping

No

Ripping & burning

No

Burning (Soundtrack Pro)

MP3

License Fee

Yes

Yes

No

Download LAME encoder

Yes

Yes

OMF

Yes

Yes

Yes

No

Yes

No

Yes

Project Physical Folder

Optional

Yes

Yes

Yes

Yes

No

Yes

Project Logical Folder

Project Files panel facilitates tracking but no management

Pool facilitates tracking & management

Project Browser and clip List facilitate tracking and management

Project file management function

Soundbite Window facilitates tracking & management

File tracking not included in Current Project folder

Bin facilitates tracking & management

Consolidated Export

Save As & .bun

Save to New Folder

Save Copy

Collect All & Save

Save Copy

Save as .zip

Save As

Fast Bounce

Yes

Yes

No

Yes

Yes

Yes

Yes

Logical Library

No

Media Manager

No

No

No

No

Apple Loop Library

File Metadata

No

Can maintain extensive metadata in MediaBay

Can store some metadata using Project & Workspace Browsers

No

Can store some metadata using Sound File Info Window

No

No

Cleanup

Facility for finding unused audio files

Facility for finding unused audio files

Facility for finding unused audio files

File Management function

Facility for finding unused audio files

No facility for finding unused audio

Facility for finding unused audio files

Overall Rating

 

 

 

Go to Ratings

Explain the Rating

What is this?

Explain the rating

Summary

Sonar X1

Cubase 6

Pro Tools 10

Live 8

Digital Performer 7

FL Studio 10

Logic Pro 9

Category

Surround Mixing

Output Formats

30 formats

9 formats

No

No

6 formats

No

6 formats

Surround Panner Views

1 panner view

3 panner views

No

No

4 panner views

No

1 panner view

Low Frequency Effects (LFE) Control

Volume & cutoff

Volume

No

No

Volume & cutoff

No

Volume

Surround FX

SurroundBridge

Independent channel routing, common plug-in settings

No

No

17 surround FX

No

Multichannel FX Configuration

Stereo Mixdown

Center level, LFE level, & surround level controls in project setup

Plug-in available to control individual surround channel volumes

No

No

Automatic downmix, but no control of surround channels

No

Plug-in available to control individual surround channel volumes

Export

Interleaved & split mono for multiple file formats

Interleaved & split mono for multiple file formats

No

No

Interleaved & split mono for multiple file formats

No

Interleaved & split mono for multiple file formats

Overall Rating

 

 

 

 

 

Go to Ratings

Explain the Rating

What is this?

Explain the rating

Summary

Sonar X1

Cubase 6

Pro Tools 10

Live 8

Digital Performer 7

FL Studio 10

Logic Pro 9

Category

Recording & Editing

Multi-Track Recording

Yes

Yes

Yes

Yes

Yes

Yes

Yes

Multiple Takes

Separate clips in a single track displayed vertically or stacked

Separate events in a single track displayed vertically or stacked

Separate clips stacked and listed in clips List

Single clip for all takes

Separate audio soundbites in a single track displayed vertically or stacked

Multiple takes create multiple channels

Separate events/parts in a single track displayed vertically or stacked

Composites

Separate clips in a single track displayed vertically or stacked

Separate events in a single track displayed vertically or stacked

Separate clips stacked and listed in clips List

Single clip for all takes

Separate audio soundbites in a single track displayed vertically or stacked

Multiple takes create multiple channels

Separate events/parts in a single track displayed vertically or stacked

Overlay Modes

Sound on Sound, Overwrite

Merge, Replace

Destructive, Non-Destructive

MIDI overlay only

Overdub & replace

Merge, Replace

Merge, Replace

Punch In/Out

Yes

Yes

Yes

Yes

Yes

No

Yes

Input Monitoring

Yes

Yes

Yes

Yes

Yes

Yes

Yes

Editors

Clips Pane

Sample Editor & Audio Part Editor

Edit Window

Sample Browser

Waveform

Edison

Sample Editor & Soundtrack Pro

Overall Rating

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

Overall Rating

 

 

 

Digital
Producer
Digital
Arranger
Digital
Performer 7
Music for
Media
Pro
Tools 10
Sound Forge 10 Mix &
Master
Ableton
Live 8
Logic
Pro 9
FL Studio
10
About
Us
Press
Releases

Copyright © 2004-2011 Digital Music Doctor LLC All Rights Reserved
Digital Music Doctor ® is a Registered Trademark of Digital Music Doctor LLC